MULTIPLE ACCESS TECHNIQUES IN TELECOMMUNICATIONS NETWORKS
By Adeyinka Olumuyiwa Osunwusi, PhD.
Radio frequency spectrum is both a limited and valuable intangible spectral resource. This fact underscores the need for the efficient and cooperative use of electromagnetic spectrum such that a large number of users are able to share an allocated spectrum in an efficient manner in order to achieve high capacity and increased spectral efficiency. Typically, the multiple users seeking to use a single channel simultaneously are geographically dispersed with each of them making sporadic attempts to execute communications at the same time. From the perspective of service or operation, there are three distinct types of communication directions – often referred to as duplexing techniques – when it comes to access operations in telecommunications networks, be they wired or wireless.
The first is what is called simplex operation, which defines a one-way communication with only a forward channel and no response channel. The second is half-duplex, which defines a two-way operation, albeit transmission generally takes place only in one direction at a given time. Thirdly, there is the full duplex operation, which defines a two-way service characterized by simultaneous transmissions in both directions. Duplexing allows telecommunication users to send and receive information simultaneously. Duplexing techniques can take a number of forms including FDD (frequency division duplexing) and TDD (time division duplexing).
Two methods allow for the efficient sharing of access by multiple potential communicators in telecommunications networks: multiplexing techniques and multiple access schemes. Access sharing, talking from the perspective of digital data communications, can also be based on a multiple access protocol and control mechanism, known as Media (or Medium) Access Control (MAC).
Multiplexing as a sharing method involves combining several signals into a composite signal, specifically at the IF band or what is often referred to as the baseband level. Multiplexing essentially provides the means for ensuring the efficient sharing of a communications channel in frequency, time and space through the process of combining multiple signals into a composite signal known as a multiplex. One unique thing about multiplexing is that the combined multiple signals remain distinctly independent of one another with a particular signal not interfering with other signals sharing the same signal spectrum.
There are several techniques of multiplexing signals today. These include Frequency Division Multiplexing (FDM), Time Division Multiplexing (TDM), Code Division Multiplexing (CDM), Polarization Division Multiplexing (PDM) and Wavelength Division Multiplexing (WDM) – which enjoys wide application in optical communications – and Space (or Spatial) Division Multiplexing (SDM). FDM finds application typically in analogue transmission systems while TDM finds useful application in digital systems. There is also the Orthogonal Frequency Division Multiplexing (OFDM) on which the L-Band Digital Aeronautical Communications System’s (LDAC) modulation is based. Orbital Angular Momentum Multiplexing (OAMM) is an emerging multiplexing technique, which is being explored for millimeter wave communications. With characteristic orthogonal beams that are defined by a different OAM (orbital angular momentum) state number, OAMM uses the helical phase front property of an electromagnetic wave to multiplex multiple coaxial beams.
Multiple access techniques, on their part, are implemented at the RF band level. A multiple access scheme defines the access method that is employed to allow multiple telecommunication users –through the use of an appropriate multiplexing technique – to access and share a common communications channel typically in a wireless telecommunication network. Multiple access schemes are typically applicable to multiple channel per carrier (MCPC) access scenarios as opposed to single channel per carrier (SCPC) applications. Although a huge number of sharing methods have been developed and are also been actively explored, the multiple access techniques that have been garnering the highest usage across telecommunication networks are Frequency Division Multiple Access (FDMA) and Time Division Multiple Access (TDMA), which are defined by access schemes that are based on the frequency domain and the time domain respectively. There is also the Demand-Assigned Multiple Access (DAMA) scheme, which is unique to satellite communications.
Code Division Multiple Access (CDMA) – a generic access method like FDMA and TDMA – and Multi Frequency-Time Division Multiple Access (MF-TDMA) are also finding increasing applications in the telecommunications industry. For some applications, the Orthogonal Frequency Division Multiple Access (OFDMA) and the random multiple access Carrier Sense Multiple Access (CSMA) – which has been finding increasing applications in LANs – are also exhibiting their capabilities, while an OFDMA variant, the Non-Orthogonal Multiple Access (NOMA), continues to be actively explored, particularly for 6G technology applications. There are also less common multiple access techniques such as the Polarization Division Multiple Access (PDMA) and the Space (or Spatial) Division Multiple Access (SDMA), which is still under development. These access schemes make use of resources such as frequency, time, and space. In many telecommunications applications, a combination of the resources is usually featured in order to increase capacity as well as enhance flexibility and efficiency. The implication, therefore, is that meeting the ever-changing demands of digital telecommunications will require a combination of multiple access techniques rather than the use of a single access technique.
ACCESS BASED ON FREQUENCY AND TIME DOMAINS
The FDMA, which is traditionally an analogue system, is typically used in satellite communications and 5G cellular technologies. Historically, FDMA is the multiple access method for cellular systems and it is usually implemented in narrowband systems. It is somewhat related to Wavelength Division Multiple Access (WDMA) – widely used in optical communications systems – where wavelengths are used for propagation within a single optical fiber.
As a frequency domain assigned access technique, FDMA allows multiple users to share an allocated spectrum at the same time by dividing the spectrum into separate frequency bands and assigning each user a dedicated frequency slot for communication. Access is generally on a single-channel-per-carrier (SCPC) basis or multiple-channel-per-carrier (MCPC) basis. All users are, thus, able to communicate simultaneous and continuously on their assigned channels. This fact presupposes the importance of filtering (using bandpass filters) with respect to the frequency domain in order to ensure interference-free signal separation, a requirement that is unnecessary in TDMA systems. One problem, though, remains that of spectral resource idleness as an assigned FDMA channel cannot be used by other users in the network when that particular channel is not in use.
The Nigerian Aeronautical Satellite Telecommunication Network, which is an integral part of the Satellite Telecommunication Network for Central and Western Africa (now known as the AFISNET network) operating at the C-Band (6/4 GHz) based on the INTELSAT Standard B/ Standard F1 configurations at 64 kb/s using ¾ Forward-Error-Correction techniques, for example, is anchored on the FDMA scheme. Operating on a transponder aboard Intelsat 10.02 satellite, the network’s usable bandwidth of 36 MHz is subdivided into smaller bandwidths that are assigned to users. The 36 MHz bandwidth occupies one of the 12 segments (or transponders) of the total satellite bandwidth, which is typically 500 MHz for a C-band, Ku-band or Ka-band satellite system. With an IF of 70 MHz, a total of 1600 channels are made available for a terminal. Given a bandwidth of 36 MHz and an IF of 70 MHz±18 MHz,
1 channel = 36 MHz/1600
= 22.5 kHz.
The step or spacing of each channel within the dedicated 36 MHz is, therefore, 22.5 kHz. For a typical GSM cellular use case, however, the useable frequency of 25 MHz is divided into 124 carrier frequencies that are spaced at 200 kHz to yield a total of 125 channels.
Frequency management is an important requirement in an FDMA operational terrain. The FDMA, in spite of its wide application, has limitations in terms of channel capacity and operational flexibility with a fixed bit-rate per channel. However, capacity can be increased considerably in FDMA systems by implementing a robust digital coding scheme as well as lowering information bit rate. Given the limitation of frequency spectrum, there is the problem of frequency slot saturation where the population of potential users outstrips the number of available frequency slots. In terms of system complexity, FDMA requires the implementation of dedicated MODEM at the baseband level for each of the communicators thus creating difficulty in terms of cost-effectiveness. However, FDMA systems are advantageous when it comes to hardware simplicity and the simplicity of channel assignment as they are not as complex as the time-domain assigned TDMA. In satellite applications, there are also disadvantages regarding intermodulation products problem and the inability to maximize the use of the power of the satellite transponder. Thus, the need for a close coordination of uplink power levels becomes constantly imperative. In other words, a transponder cannot be operated at maximum power without facing the need to back off the input, thus downgrading capacity and efficiency.
The industry, however, continues to devise techniques for mitigating the disadvantages of FDMA. One is the effective reuse of frequency slots in order to accommodate as many users as possible. In cellular applications, multiple users are located in separate cells within a frequency slot and can simultaneously make use of the frequency segment provided the users are sufficiently geographically dispersed in an attempt to preclude the signal of one cell from affecting the signal of another cell using the same frequency segment.
The TDMA, on its part, is a time domain-assigned multiple access technique where timing synchronization is a crucial factor. This timing requirement necessarily requires the implementation of a centralized monitoring and control station which not only transmits a periodic TDM-format reference burst in the form of a frame divided into time slots but also ensures that each user in the network transmits at its individual assigned time slot. This synchronization, though, is not a requirement for FDMA operations. The configuration of a TDMA frame – consisting of a number (N) of time slots – is such that each time-slot usually integrates user data bits, bits for synchronization, guard times, control, and so on. Sufficient guard times are inserted between each user’s transmissions to mitigate crosstalk and clock instability effects.
TDMA is also a largely digital access scheme, which typically employs both phase shift keying modulation and time division multiplexing at the baseband level. Its application covers both wireless and wired digital communications terrains. In TDMA, the signals of different multiple users are separated and assigned separate time segments in a sequential manner and on a one-user-per-slot basis, albeit a user can make use of multiple slots. Although all the communicators in a TDMA system operate on a single carrier frequency, different non-overlapping time slots are allocated for transmission and reception using TDD. This effectively makes the implementation of duplexers unnecessary. Unlike FDMA, TDMA is superior in terms of capacity and flexibility as accesses are quite re-configurable at any time and different numbers of time-slots per frame can be assigned to different communicators. Transmission is also non-continuous in TDMA systems unlike FDMA where transmission takes place continuously and simultaneously.
In satellite communications applications, TDMA allows the transponder to be operated at full power as each user has exclusive and complete use of the frequency band during its assigned time slot, an advantage that FDMA lacks. Additionally, TDMA removes problems associated with overlapping and intermodulation interference among individual carriers. This notwithstanding, TDMA suffers from negligible time delays as communications are stored or queued in a buffer on occasions where the number of requests for time slots to use a communications channel from potential users outstrips the number of available time slots. Two notable disadvantages of TDMA, particularly for cellular system applications, are problems associated with the requirement for guard space (especially when used with FDMA) for users-separation and complex time synchronization. There is also the limitation of a high peak power demand on the uplink which elevates power consumption and shortens battery life. A growing number of mobile networks are, therefore, embracing using TDMA in combination with FDMA or SDMA in order to boost the population of users.
The demand-assigned multiple access (DAMA) is typically applicable to the satellite communication terrain. Because the access method is in the frequency domain, DAMA can be categorized as a subset of FDMA as it allows for bandwidth-sharing such that multiple users are granted access to the sharing of a pool of resources or channels available for assignment on demand. In this manner, a single transponder is used to support several users strictly on call-by-call basis. When a user activates a request, a network control system validates the request and assigns a channel for communication. Upon the completion of a call on the assigned channel, a notification to this effect is received by the control system and the channel is returned to the pool of channels for reassignment on demand.
The MF-TDMA effectively combines the affordances of both the FDMA and the TDMA. The idea is to divide the available frequency band into separate frequency sub-bands with each frequency sub-band further divided into time-slots. Multiple users are then assigned, in a dynamic manner, specific time slots and frequency sub-bands for communications. This assignment is necessarily predicated upon the demands and the bandwidth capabilities of individual users. Although FDMA is noted for permitting simultaneous and continuous transmission, the time domain dependency of MF-TDMA prevents the multiple users on the network from transmitting simultaneously in the same frequency band. This is necessary for precluding interference. The multiple carrier frequencies, though, can be operated with different power levels.
The OFDMA – an upgraded variant of the OFDM technique – is another frequency – and time-domain access scheme that divides the available channel into a number of independently modulating subcarriers and assigns each user a subset of the closely-spaced and orthogonal subcarriers, thus allowing multiple users to communicate simultaneously. This allows for improved network efficiency and increased capacity through low latency and the elimination of network congestion, albeit OFDMA exhibits a great deal of sensitivity to frequency offset. The defining characteristics of OFDMA are its robust spatial diversity, receiver circuit simplicity and intrinsic orthogonality. Additionally, it is possible in OFDMA systems to dynamically change the allocation of subcarriers to users. Another important advantage of OFDMA is the capability of the scheme to combine the use of a multiplicity of low data rate subcarriers (with long symbol duration) with the insertion of cyclic extension or cyclic prefix to address issues surrounding multipath interference.
The OFDMA finds growing applications in cellular standards such as WiMAX and LTE (Long Term Evolution). It is also a crucial feature of Wi-Fi 6/Wi-Fi 7, WMAN (wireless metropolitan area network) and the futuristic air-ground broadband digital datalink system known as L-Band Digital Aeronautical Communications System (LDACS), which utilizes the OFDM modulation technique. The LDAC protocol stack’s physical layer, though, supports the Forward-Reverse transfers of data using a combination of OFDMA and TDMA schemes. On the forward link, an LDAC ground station supports the continuous transmission of a stream of OFDM symbols as well as bi-directional communication links to multiple air traffic, while, on the reverse link, multiple traffic can transmit discontinuously, transmitting a combination of TDMA and OFDMA radio bursts in frequency and time in accordance with the slots assigned to the different traffic on demand by the ground station.
CODE SEQUENCE-DEPENDENT ACCESS TECHNIQUES
CDMA allows multiple users to simultaneously share a common bandwidth at the same time with each user assigned a unique pseudorandom identification code or user-specific signature that is modulated with the useful information such that the useful information in the signals transmitted by the users are extracted by the receivers using the unique codes in the signals, which are essentially orthogonal to each other. This process involves the multiplication of the signal by the code sequence. This multiplication process effectively spreads the power of the transmitted signal over a larger bandwidth, increasing the bandwidth efficiency of CDMA in a network with several users. This spread spectrum technique – with its intrinsic characteristics including asynchronous access capability and significant immunity to unauthorized interception and multi-path propagation distortion – explains why CDMA is sometimes called spread-spectrum multiple access (SSMA), a somewhat frequency-time matrix access technique.
CDMA is robust in terms of its flexibility. However, CDMA requires the deployment of complex receivers. There is also the need for complex power control intervention to mitigate near-far problem, specifically in relation to mobile technology. This power control intervention is not associated with TDMA where inter-user interference is mitigated using frequency and time-slot allocation.
NEXT-GENERATION MULTIPLE ACCESS SCHEMES
One emerging multiple access scheme that is being actively developed is the Non-Orthogonal Multiple Access (NOMA), which allows multiple users to communicate simultaneously in the same frequency band using superposition coding. The access is anchored on non-orthogonal resource assignment just like SDMA (Space Division Multiple Access). The SDMA technique, on its part, is a space-domain assigned multiple access scheme that is being explored for satellite communications and 6G technologies. It implements spatial division multiplexing involving multiple spatially separated aperture pairs for the uplink and downlink paths. In SDMA, a given space is segmented into smaller sectors which are assigned to different users in the form of spatial locations based on beam forming schemes. SDMA is essentially a multi-antenna system, which uses multiple antennas to provide multiple data streams – via the superposition of several spot beams – to different users simultaneously in the same channel. In satellite communications, the footprint of each spot beam is on a different region. Although SDMA is a top-notch technique in terms of high spectral efficiency, the scheme has a number of disadvantages including its characteristic inflexibility, and relatively poor synchronization. The utility of the scheme can, however, be very robust when used in combination with CDMA, FDMA, OFDMA or TDMA.
Another technique worth mentioning is PDMA, which is being largely explored for satellite communications. It is also a multi-antenna system using separate receivers and separate antennas with different polarizations. PDMA modulation does not involve frequency, amplitude or phase modulation. Rather, it uses the electromagnetic wave’s circular propagation characteristic for modulation.
CONCLUSION
Multiple access schemes provide the means for allowing multiple telecommunications users to communicate on a single channel using one or a combination of resources such as time, frequency and space. Given the frenzied evolution of technology and the growing demands for more efficient, scalable and robust telecommunications networks, it is becoming increasingly apparent that a single multiple access scheme cannot meet existing and emerging operational realities. This is, expectedly, driving a paradigm shift towards the implementation of multiple access schemes that combine the affordances of at least two multiple access techniques.
It is worth noting that in terms of the fundamentals of access in relation to resources as well as assignment and control mechanisms, FDMA – and also CDMA and TDMA – are the same in both satellite and cellular technology applications. However, there are marked differences when it comes to the aspects of affordances, limitations, and parameter configurations. ◙
All rights reserved. No part of this material or the content of this website may be reproduced or published in any form or by any means without the prior written permission of the publisher.
Contact: atsei@dextermarie.com